Extra Space Storage

1775 5th Ave, Bay Shore NY, 11706

(888) 291-4801 Call Now!

Reserve a storage unit with Extra Space Storage

Book now to secure your storage unit.

See facility on map

Office Hours

Mon-Fri 09:30 AM - 06:00 PM
Sat 09:00 AM - 05:30 PM
Sun CLOSED

Access Hours

Mon-Sun 06:00 AM - 10:00 PM

Facility Amenities

5 x 5 Small Unit

Climate Controlled

Indoor

Elevator Access

Upper Floor
Reserve FREE, No obligation to rent

Continue

Reserve this unit for FREE
LOCK in this unit rate. Month to month rentals. No deposit required.

Move-in date is flexible upto 13 days. If you are not sure of the date you are moving in, choose an approximate date, you can change it later.

Move-in date is flexible upto 13 days. If you are not sure of the date you are moving in, choose an approximate date, you can change it later.

By clicking reserve now you agree to our terms of use

Web Only Price $32.00_/month $32.00_/month Web Only Price
~~$55.00~~_/month

~~$55.00~~_/month

Up to 50% OFF - Act Fast, Hold This Unit!
Continue

Up to 50% OFF - Act Fast, Hold This Unit!
5 x 5 Small Unit

Climate Controlled

Indoor

First Floor Access
Reserve FREE, No obligation to rent

Continue

Reserve this unit for FREE
LOCK in this unit rate. Month to month rentals. No deposit required.

Move-in date is flexible upto 6 days. If you are not sure of the date you are moving in, choose an approximate date, you can change it later.

Move-in date is flexible upto 6 days. If you are not sure of the date you are moving in, choose an approximate date, you can change it later.

By clicking reserve now you agree to our terms of use

Web Only Price $34.00_/month $34.00_/month Web Only Price
~~$69.00~~_/month

~~$69.00~~_/month

Up to 50% OFF - Act Fast, Hold This Unit!
Continue

Up to 50% OFF - Act Fast, Hold This Unit!
5 x 8 Small Unit

Climate Controlled

Indoor

Elevator Access

Upper Floor
Reserve FREE, No obligation to rent

Continue

Reserve this unit for FREE
LOCK in this unit rate. Month to month rentals. No deposit required.

Move-in date is flexible upto 13 days. If you are not sure of the date you are moving in, choose an approximate date, you can change it later.

Move-in date is flexible upto 13 days. If you are not sure of the date you are moving in, choose an approximate date, you can change it later.

By clicking reserve now you agree to our terms of use

Web Only Price $47.00_/month $47.00_/month Web Only Price
~~$80.00~~_/month

~~$80.00~~_/month

Up to 50% OFF - Act Fast, Hold This Unit!
Continue

Up to 50% OFF - Act Fast, Hold This Unit!
5 x 10 Small Unit

Climate Controlled

Indoor

Elevator Access

Upper Floor
Reserve FREE, No obligation to rent

Continue

Reserve this unit for FREE
LOCK in this unit rate. Month to month rentals. No deposit required.

Move-in date is flexible upto 13 days. If you are not sure of the date you are moving in, choose an approximate date, you can change it later.

Move-in date is flexible upto 13 days. If you are not sure of the date you are moving in, choose an approximate date, you can change it later.

By clicking reserve now you agree to our terms of use

Web Only Price $46.00_/month $46.00_/month Web Only Price
~~$94.00~~_/month

~~$94.00~~_/month

Up to 50% OFF - Act Fast, Hold This Unit!
Continue

Up to 50% OFF - Act Fast, Hold This Unit!
5 x 10 Small Unit

Climate Controlled

Indoor

First Floor Access
Reserve FREE, No obligation to rent

Continue

Reserve this unit for FREE
LOCK in this unit rate. Month to month rentals. No deposit required.

Move-in date is flexible upto 6 days. If you are not sure of the date you are moving in, choose an approximate date, you can change it later.

Move-in date is flexible upto 6 days. If you are not sure of the date you are moving in, choose an approximate date, you can change it later.

By clicking reserve now you agree to our terms of use

Web Only Price $66.00_/month $66.00_/month Web Only Price
~~$113.00~~_/month

~~$113.00~~_/month

Up to 50% OFF - Act Fast, Hold This Unit!
Continue

Up to 50% OFF - Act Fast, Hold This Unit!
7 x 10 Medium Unit

Climate Controlled

Indoor

First Floor Access
Reserve FREE, No obligation to rent

Continue

Reserve this unit for FREE
LOCK in this unit rate. Month to month rentals. No deposit required.

Move-in date is flexible upto 6 days. If you are not sure of the date you are moving in, choose an approximate date, you can change it later.

Move-in date is flexible upto 6 days. If you are not sure of the date you are moving in, choose an approximate date, you can change it later.

By clicking reserve now you agree to our terms of use

Web Only Price $70.00_/month $70.00_/month Web Only Price
~~$144.00~~_/month

~~$144.00~~_/month

Up to 50% OFF - Act Fast, Hold This Unit!
Continue

Up to 50% OFF - Act Fast, Hold This Unit!
7 x 15 Medium Unit

Climate Controlled

Indoor

First Floor Access
Reserve FREE, No obligation to rent

Continue

Reserve this unit for FREE
LOCK in this unit rate. Month to month rentals. No deposit required.

Move-in date is flexible upto 6 days. If you are not sure of the date you are moving in, choose an approximate date, you can change it later.

Move-in date is flexible upto 6 days. If you are not sure of the date you are moving in, choose an approximate date, you can change it later.

By clicking reserve now you agree to our terms of use

Web Only Price $89.00_/month $89.00_/month Web Only Price
~~$177.00~~_/month

~~$177.00~~_/month

Up to 50% OFF - Act Fast, Hold This Unit!
Continue

Up to 50% OFF - Act Fast, Hold This Unit!
8 x 10 Medium Unit

Climate Controlled

Indoor

Elevator Access

Upper Floor
Reserve FREE, No obligation to rent

Continue

Reserve this unit for FREE
LOCK in this unit rate. Month to month rentals. No deposit required.

Move-in date is flexible upto 13 days. If you are not sure of the date you are moving in, choose an approximate date, you can change it later.

Move-in date is flexible upto 13 days. If you are not sure of the date you are moving in, choose an approximate date, you can change it later.

By clicking reserve now you agree to our terms of use

Web Only Price $64.00_/month $64.00_/month Web Only Price
~~$132.00~~_/month

~~$132.00~~_/month

Up to 50% OFF - Act Fast, Hold This Unit!
Continue

Up to 50% OFF - Act Fast, Hold This Unit!
10 x 5 Small Unit

Climate Controlled

Indoor

First Floor Access
Reserve FREE, No obligation to rent

Continue

Reserve this unit for FREE
LOCK in this unit rate. Month to month rentals. No deposit required.

Move-in date is flexible upto 6 days. If you are not sure of the date you are moving in, choose an approximate date, you can change it later.

Move-in date is flexible upto 6 days. If you are not sure of the date you are moving in, choose an approximate date, you can change it later.

By clicking reserve now you agree to our terms of use

Web Only Price $55.00_/month $55.00_/month Web Only Price
~~$113.00~~_/month

~~$113.00~~_/month

Up to 50% OFF - Act Fast, Hold This Unit!
Continue

Up to 50% OFF - Act Fast, Hold This Unit!
10 x 10 Medium Unit

Climate Controlled

Indoor

First Floor Access
Reserve FREE, No obligation to rent

Continue

Reserve this unit for FREE
LOCK in this unit rate. Month to month rentals. No deposit required.

Move-in date is flexible upto 6 days. If you are not sure of the date you are moving in, choose an approximate date, you can change it later.

Move-in date is flexible upto 6 days. If you are not sure of the date you are moving in, choose an approximate date, you can change it later.

By clicking reserve now you agree to our terms of use

Web Only Price $107.00_/month $107.00_/month Web Only Price
~~$171.00~~_/month

~~$171.00~~_/month

Up to 50% OFF - Act Fast, Hold This Unit!
Continue

Up to 50% OFF - Act Fast, Hold This Unit!
10 x 10 Medium Unit

Climate Controlled

Indoor

Elevator Access

Upper Floor
Reserve FREE, No obligation to rent

Continue

Reserve this unit for FREE
LOCK in this unit rate. Month to month rentals. No deposit required.

Move-in date is flexible upto 6 days. If you are not sure of the date you are moving in, choose an approximate date, you can change it later.

Move-in date is flexible upto 6 days. If you are not sure of the date you are moving in, choose an approximate date, you can change it later.

By clicking reserve now you agree to our terms of use

Web Only Price $107.00_/month $107.00_/month Web Only Price
~~$170.00~~_/month

~~$170.00~~_/month

Up to 50% OFF - Act Fast, Hold This Unit!
Continue

Up to 50% OFF - Act Fast, Hold This Unit!
10 x 15 Medium Unit

Climate Controlled

Indoor

First Floor Access
Reserve FREE, No obligation to rent

Continue

Reserve this unit for FREE
LOCK in this unit rate. Month to month rentals. No deposit required.

Move-in date is flexible upto 6 days. If you are not sure of the date you are moving in, choose an approximate date, you can change it later.

Move-in date is flexible upto 6 days. If you are not sure of the date you are moving in, choose an approximate date, you can change it later.

By clicking reserve now you agree to our terms of use

Web Only Price $109.00_/month $109.00_/month Web Only Price
~~$237.00~~_/month

~~$237.00~~_/month

Up to 50% OFF - Act Fast, Hold This Unit!
Continue

Up to 50% OFF - Act Fast, Hold This Unit!
10 x 20 Large Unit

PARKING

Car, Boat, RV

Uncovered
Reserve FREE, No obligation to rent

Continue

Reserve this unit for FREE
LOCK in this unit rate. Month to month rentals. No deposit required.

Move-in date is flexible upto 2 days. If you are not sure of the date you are moving in, choose an approximate date, you can change it later.

Move-in date is flexible upto 2 days. If you are not sure of the date you are moving in, choose an approximate date, you can change it later.

By clicking reserve now you agree to our terms of use

Web Only Price $90.00_/month $90.00_/month Web Only Price
~~$163.00~~_/month

~~$163.00~~_/month

Up to 50% OFF - Act Fast, Hold This Unit!
Continue

Up to 50% OFF - Act Fast, Hold This Unit!
10 x 20 Large Unit

Climate Controlled

Indoor

First Floor Access
Reserve FREE, No obligation to rent

Continue

Reserve this unit for FREE
LOCK in this unit rate. Month to month rentals. No deposit required.

Move-in date is flexible upto 2 days. If you are not sure of the date you are moving in, choose an approximate date, you can change it later.

Move-in date is flexible upto 2 days. If you are not sure of the date you are moving in, choose an approximate date, you can change it later.

By clicking reserve now you agree to our terms of use

Web Only Price $222.00_/month $222.00_/month Web Only Price
~~$334.00~~_/month

~~$334.00~~_/month

Up to 50% OFF - Act Fast, Hold This Unit!
Continue

Up to 50% OFF - Act Fast, Hold This Unit!
20 x 15 Large Unit

Climate Controlled

Indoor

First Floor Access
Reserve FREE, No obligation to rent

Continue

Reserve this unit for FREE
LOCK in this unit rate. Month to month rentals. No deposit required.

Move-in date is flexible upto 2 days. If you are not sure of the date you are moving in, choose an approximate date, you can change it later.

Move-in date is flexible upto 2 days. If you are not sure of the date you are moving in, choose an approximate date, you can change it later.

By clicking reserve now you agree to our terms of use

Web Only Price $258.00_/month $258.00_/month Web Only Price
~~$446.00~~_/month

~~$446.00~~_/month

Up to 50% OFF - Act Fast, Hold This Unit!
Continue

Up to 50% OFF - Act Fast, Hold This Unit!

LOWEST RATES AND PRICES GUARANTEED

3 x 5 Unit
Climate Controlled

Indoor

Elevator Access

Upper Floor
(888) 291-4801 Call Now! Call now for availability

Reserve for FREE
3 x 5 Unit
Climate Controlled

Indoor

First Floor Access
(888) 291-4801 Call Now! Call now for availability

Reserve for FREE
4 x 5 Unit
Climate Controlled

Indoor

Elevator Access

Upper Floor
(888) 291-4801 Call Now! Call now for availability

Reserve for FREE
5 x 6 Unit
Climate Controlled

Indoor

Elevator Access

Upper Floor
(888) 291-4801 Call Now! Call now for availability

Reserve for FREE
5 x 7 Unit
Climate Controlled

Indoor

Elevator Access

Upper Floor
(888) 291-4801 Call Now! Call now for availability

Reserve for FREE
5 x 8 Unit
Climate Controlled

Indoor

First Floor Access
(888) 291-4801 Call Now! Call now for availability

Reserve for FREE
5 x 15 Unit
Climate Controlled

Indoor

First Floor Access
(888) 291-4801 Call Now! Call now for availability

Reserve for FREE
6 x 10 Unit
Climate Controlled

Indoor

Elevator Access

Upper Floor
(888) 291-4801 Call Now! Call now for availability

Reserve for FREE
7 x 10 Unit
Climate Controlled

Indoor

Elevator Access

Upper Floor
(888) 291-4801 Call Now! Call now for availability

Reserve for FREE
7 x 20 Unit
Climate Controlled

Indoor

First Floor Access
(888) 291-4801 Call Now! Call now for availability

Reserve for FREE
8 x 8 Unit
Climate Controlled

Indoor

Elevator Access

Upper Floor
(888) 291-4801 Call Now! Call now for availability

Reserve for FREE
8 x 10 Unit
Climate Controlled

Indoor

First Floor Access
(888) 291-4801 Call Now! Call now for availability

Reserve for FREE
8 x 15 Unit
Climate Controlled

Indoor

First Floor Access
(888) 291-4801 Call Now! Call now for availability

Reserve for FREE
8 x 20 Unit
Climate Controlled

Indoor

First Floor Access
(888) 291-4801 Call Now! Call now for availability

Reserve for FREE
10 x 15 Unit
Climate Controlled

Indoor

Elevator Access

Upper Floor
(888) 291-4801 Call Now! Call now for availability

Reserve for FREE
10 x 25 Unit
Climate Controlled

Indoor

First Floor Access
(888) 291-4801 Call Now! Call now for availability

Reserve for FREE
10 x 30 Unit
Climate Controlled

Indoor

First Floor Access
(888) 291-4801 Call Now! Call now for availability

Reserve for FREE
10 x 40 Unit
PARKING

Car, Boat, RV

Uncovered
(888) 291-4801 Call Now! Call now for availability

Reserve for FREE
15 x 20 Unit
Climate Controlled

Indoor

First Floor Access
(888) 291-4801 Call Now! Call now for availability

Reserve for FREE
20 x 10 Unit
Climate Controlled

Indoor

Elevator Access

Upper Floor
(888) 291-4801 Call Now! Call now for availability

Reserve for FREE

LOWEST RATES AND PRICES GUARANTEED

Office Hours

Mon-Fri 09:30 AM - 06:00 PM
Sat 09:00 AM - 05:30 PM
Sun CLOSED

Access Hours

Mon-Sun 06:00 AM - 10:00 PM

Facility Amenities

Customers Review

Nina T.

September 09, 2023 - From Extra Space

Just got a unit here in N. Bayshore/Brentwood area. Large, clean facility. David and Anthony were very helpful and thorough.
Théodore L.

September 08, 2023 - From Extra Space

David, was very helpful. He really helped me through upgrading from 5x5 to 5x10. Very patient, thx a lot bro.
Eduardo C.

September 01, 2023 - From Extra Space

Excelente ayuda
William S.

August 11, 2023 - From Extra Space

From my first call, second call and going to location everyone was pleasant, patient and helpful. I needed to see if our RV could fit, Brendan showed me the site and spent all the time I needed to decide. He went over every detail of the rental agreement, with no rush.
Abraham C.

August 09, 2023 - From Extra Space

I had a excellent and smooth transition , i will definitely tell my friends about this.....
Erick V.

August 08, 2023 - From Extra Space

Very helpful, awesome customer service by Anthony.
Frankie L.

August 05, 2023 - From Extra Space

Fast, clean, and the employees were really knowledgeable.
See more

All Sizes

5 x 5 (Small)

5 x 10 (Small)

10 x 10 (Medium)

10 x 15 (Medium)

10 x 20 (Large)

10 x 30 (Large)

All Sizes

5 x 10 (Enclosed)

10 x 10 (Enclosed)

20’ Parking

30’ Parking

Small RV

Large RV

Extra Space Storage

1775 5th Ave, Bay Shore NY, 11706

Reserve a storage unit with Extra Space Storage

Book now to secure your storage unit.

All Sizes

5 x 5 (Small)

5 x 10 (Small)

10 x 10 (Medium)

10 x 15 (Medium)

10 x 20 (Large)

10 x 30 (Large)

All Sizes

5 x 10 (Enclosed)

10 x 10 (Enclosed)

20’ Parking

30’ Parking

Small RV

Large RV

Climate Controlled

Indoor

Elevator Access

Upper Floor

Climate Controlled

Indoor

First Floor Access

Climate Controlled

Indoor

Elevator Access

Upper Floor

Climate Controlled

Indoor

Elevator Access

Upper Floor

Climate Controlled

Indoor

First Floor Access

Climate Controlled

Indoor

First Floor Access

Climate Controlled

Indoor

First Floor Access

Climate Controlled

Indoor

Elevator Access

Upper Floor

Climate Controlled

Indoor

First Floor Access

Climate Controlled

Indoor

First Floor Access

Climate Controlled

Indoor

Elevator Access

Upper Floor

Climate Controlled

Indoor

First Floor Access

PARKING

Car, Boat, RV

Uncovered

Climate Controlled

Indoor

First Floor Access

Climate Controlled